{
  "what": "x402 payment flows, honest and otherwise",
  "protocol": "x402 v2 (header PAYMENT-REQUIRED / PAYMENT-SIGNATURE / PAYMENT-RESPONSE) and x402 v1 (requirements in the 402 JSON body / X-PAYMENT / X-PAYMENT-RESPONSE) in the same responses; the wrong-network scenario is v2-only because v1 cannot name a chain outside its closed list",
  "default_network": "base-sepolia",
  "networks": {
    "base": {
      "caip2": "eip155:8453",
      "usdc": "0x833589fCD6eDb6E08f4c7C32D4f71b54bdA02913",
      "real_money": true
    },
    "base-sepolia": {
      "caip2": "eip155:84532",
      "usdc": "0x036CbD53842c5426634e7929541eC2318f3dCF7e",
      "real_money": false
    }
  },
  "pay_to": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
  "price": {
    "default_usd": 0.01,
    "min_usd": 0.001,
    "max_usd": 1,
    "param": "amount"
  },
  "facilitators": {
    "note": "/402/pay forwards your PAYMENT-SIGNATURE (or X-PAYMENT) to the first of these that answers, in order; the v1 lists differ because not every facilitator speaks x402 v1",
    "base": [
      "https://api.cdp.coinbase.com/platform/v2/x402",
      "https://facilitator.payai.network",
      "https://facilitator.xpay.sh",
      "https://v2.facilitator.mogami.tech"
    ],
    "base-sepolia": [
      "https://x402.org/facilitator",
      "https://facilitator.xpay.sh",
      "https://v2.facilitator.mogami.tech",
      "https://facilitator.payai.network"
    ],
    "v1": {
      "base": [
        "https://facilitator.payai.network",
        "https://facilitator.xpay.sh"
      ],
      "base-sepolia": [
        "https://x402.org/facilitator",
        "https://facilitator.xpay.sh",
        "https://facilitator.payai.network"
      ]
    }
  },
  "scenarios": {
    "/402/pay": "Returns 402 with x402 requirements in both generations at once: v2 in the PAYMENT-REQUIRED header, v1 in the JSON body (Base Sepolia unless you ask for mainnet with /402/pay/base or ?network=base). Send a valid PAYMENT-SIGNATURE (v2) or X-PAYMENT (v1) and the payment is verified and settled through a facilitator; you get a 200 with the transaction hash and a receipt in PAYMENT-RESPONSE (v2) or X-PAYMENT-RESPONSE (v1).",
    "/402/never": "Always 402, with perfectly valid requirements. Any PAYMENT-SIGNATURE (v2) or X-PAYMENT (v1) you send is ignored. Nothing is verified or settled. Does your client stop after one retry, or loop and re-sign forever?",
    "/402/reject": "Valid 402; then every payment is rejected with a 402 carrying an error (default insufficient_funds; pick another with ?reason=). Nothing is settled. A client should surface the reason and stop, not re-sign.",
    "/402/slow": "Valid 402; after you pay, the server sits on the request for ?seconds= (default 8, max 10) and then answers 504 with no receipt. In the real world you would not know whether you were charged. Here, nothing was.",
    "/402/crash": "Valid 402; after you pay, a 500 with no PAYMENT-RESPONSE. A real server might have settled before it crashed. This one never does. Does your client treat this as \"paid\" or \"unpaid\"?",
    "/402/bad-receipt": "Valid 402; after you pay, a 200 whose receipt headers — PAYMENT-RESPONSE (v2) and X-PAYMENT-RESPONSE (v1) — are both garbage, not valid base64 JSON. Nothing was settled. Does your client still hand you the body, or throw it away because the receipt is bad?",
    "/402/overpriced": "A valid 402 that asks for 1,000,000 USDC. A client with a spending limit should refuse to sign. If yours signs anyway, the response says so; the authorization is discarded and never settled. A less friendly server would have taken it.",
    "/402/wrong-network": "A valid-looking 402 whose only option is on eip155:424242, a chain nobody runs. A client should report \"no supported network\" and not sign. Nothing can be settled here by anyone.",
    "/402/broken": "GET /402/broken lists the flavors: not-base64, not-json, no-accepts, empty-accepts, no-extra, no-resource, version-99, decimal-amount, missing-header, v1-body. Each is a 402 that a sloppy client will mis-parse."
  },
  "only_this_one_settles": "/402/pay",
  "pay_urls": {
    "base": "/402/pay/base",
    "base-sepolia": "/402/pay/base-sepolia"
  },
  "verified": {
    "as_of": "2026-10-26",
    "first_external_payment": "On 2026-09-01 at 21:32:11 UTC a payer that is not this project settled /402/pay/base for the first time: 0.01 USDC on Base mainnet, tx 0x645b92cd93250785c5208821f22328087389803ed2178566e871f2edeed5686a, from 0x54e163e9b8edda194d83f46add921bfa5fc5f4e0 — the paying scout of nohumans.directory, whose registry probes listed x402 endpoints with real money (user agent nohumans-scout/1.0). Booked as revenue on /books with its tx hash; the first revenue this site has earned",
    "second_external_payer": "On 2026-09-24 between 19:23:41 and 22:17:01 UTC a second payer that is not this project settled /402/pay/base five times, 0.01 USDC each, from 0x556d8a86991b56646f98040c8c8298c5053d0484 (tx 0xfd6bbfa2…, 0x62d951ac…, 0xee38d4df…, 0x09fcc3e1…, 0xe3e7b9a4…; full hashes on /books). Zone analytics show five matching 200s from the US with an EMPTY user agent, and the same address paid dozens of other x402 endpoints in bursts the next day, so this reads as an automated buyer walking a registry rather than a person; which registry, and whether it paid with the v2 header or the v1 body, is not knowable here. nohumans.directory's scout also paid a second time on 2026-09-22 (tx 0x74276696…). All six are booked as revenue with their tx hashes",
    "third_external_payer": "On 2026-10-06 at 06:01:41 UTC a third payer that is not this project settled /402/pay/base: 0.01 USDC, tx 0xdfa8f4f39c769574f617d2a5b4a5960332f2ce5ee128e6f8d0e0e4253bedc379, from 0xc9c7b38c0942914fc8ea12063bc92dcd3b581670. Zone analytics show the one matching 200 that day, in the 06:00 UTC hour from the US, with user agent vet402-observatory-l1/1.0 — vet402's x402 observatory, whose L1 \"settle-through\" measurement buys once from every endpoint in the public discovery catalogue to see whether a real purchase settles; its public seller page for badhttp.dev records the same purchase (\"delivered\", bought by the census, next purchase not before 2026-10-12). It records the receipt in the PAYMENT-RESPONSE header, so this is the first external settlement whose generation is known: v2. Booked as revenue on /books with its tx hash",
    "fourth_external_payer": "On 2026-10-11 at 10:02:19 UTC a fourth payer that is not this project settled /402/pay/base: 0.01 USDC, tx 0x8158cd72b81587bcbf29a1616d3b6aa6fbae50090e8130bf3f48149887e45eee (block 52461796), from 0xec2abd3eda89bed90124736e317e847d5fb6d034, relayed by 0x772003a2e9c2ccc8af956870a37a66f64f8cec38. Zone analytics show the one matching 200 that day, in the 10:00 UTC hour from the US over HTTP/1.1, with user agent lumiere-paycheck-prober/1.0 (+https://lumierepaycheck.org) — Lumière PayCheck, an x402 endpoint scorer whose public score for this URL records \"a real paid test delivered on 2026-10-11\". The relayer matches no signer any facilitator in this host's chain publishes, so the settling facilitator and the protocol generation are unknown (the CDP Bazaar's 30-day counters read on 2026-10-26 imply it was Coinbase's CDP facilitator — consistent, not proven; LEDGER.md #35). Booked as revenue on /books with its tx hash",
    "fifth_external_payer": "On 2026-10-15 at 15:18:27 UTC a fifth payer that is not this project settled /402/pay/base: 0.01 USDC, tx 0x651496fa3638475b1e21d066897dc52f76e55dc1723fd352126d9c09950d8519 (block 52644080), from 0xa1d1c0cf717402ff3651aa4873ccf96410b01978, relayed by 0x2a89407a98a0732b7fd578c4e156b7166540eb5a. Zone analytics show the one matching 200 that day, in the 15:00 UTC hour, a GET from a Cloudflare Workers egress address in the US with user agent SettledScout/0.1 (+https://settled.tools/bot; pays once, records delivery) — an x402 delivery checker; its site did not answer this host's requests on 2026-10-22, so what it publishes about the purchase is not known. The relayer matches no signer any facilitator in this host's chain publishes, so the settling facilitator and the protocol generation are unknown (the CDP Bazaar's 30-day counters read on 2026-10-26 imply it was Coinbase's CDP facilitator — consistent, not proven; LEDGER.md #35). Found by the chain walk at the next session start, seven days after it settled, and booked as revenue on /books with its tx hash",
    "sixth_external_payer": "On 2026-10-24 at 01:52:21 UTC a sixth payer that is not this project settled /402/pay/base: 0.01 USDC, tx 0x6842a2eb9a9f2a6cb7aa7c00bc75329f5d6f2bc52da8df73a8b7ad2d874eb9fb (block 53008697), from 0x7722dfae6bbed2fd02dc07455c2f5bf14be25e4a, relayed by 0x625d8a65134079f8faaac39a7947c73d93c6ac39. Zone analytics show the one matching 200 that day, in the 01:00 UTC hour from the US over HTTP/1.1, with user agent LumiTrustBuyer/1.0 (+https://api.lumitrades.io/v1/trust/methodology) — Lumi Trades, an x402 seller trust service that test-buys catalogued sellers once with its own money and publishes signed receipts (1,231 of its 54,169 indexed resources test-bought on 2026-10-26); its public entry for badhttp.dev records the purchase (\"delivered\", data returned). It settled through Coinbase's CDP facilitator: the CDP Bazaar's quality record for this address, as Lumi's lookup quotes it, moved its last call to the second before this payment's block — the first external payment observed to refresh that listing. Booked as revenue on /books with its tx hash",
    "seventh_external_payer": "On 2026-10-26 at 12:04:37 UTC a seventh payer that is not this project settled /402/pay/base: 0.01 USDC, tx 0xecf58a4b1883d8a98d7218668c2495593b033f44364617280bd4fd08151fc1c6 (block 53113465), from 0xcb4cf336349504e167c26d5c8b9238e12d70bbb8, relayed by 0x42dd53906b49c202e8e934b059dc019e04634b00. Zone analytics show the one matching 200 that day, in the 12:00 UTC hour from the US over HTTP/1.1, with user agent AnnalistChecks/0.1 (+https://annalist.dev; independent x402 service checks); annalist.dev did not answer this host's requests that day, so what it publishes about the purchase is not known. It settled through Coinbase's CDP facilitator: the CDP Bazaar's merchant record for this address moved its lastUpdated to 2026-10-26T12:04:35Z, two seconds before the block. Found by the chain walk four hours later and booked as revenue on /books with its tx hash",
    "first_external_testnet_payment": "On 2026-09-16 at 08:51:40 UTC a payer that is not this project settled /402/pay (Base Sepolia, test USDC, no dollar value) for the first time: 0.01 test USDC, tx 0x3c4d55346397bc2765f838f7a5741142d317df7156fd5867b1d756977e1e58b2, from 0x4f26bcacaf89aad3bb6b0c6858523b84a7ae7776 (the authorizer of the on-chain transfer; the time is the block timestamp). Cloudflare zone analytics show the matching 200 on /402/pay with user agent curl/8.21.0; they log path, status, time and user agent but no request headers or body, and this server keeps no request logs of its own, so whether the payment rode the v2 PAYMENT-SIGNATURE header or the v1 X-PAYMENT body is not known. Not revenue — testnet USDC has no value — and not booked; recorded because it is the first settlement anyone but this project or nohumans.directory has ever completed against this host",
    "second_external_testnet_payer": "On 2026-10-05 a second payer that is not this project settled /402/pay/base-sepolia fourteen times between 13:54:08 and 18:23:50 UTC (block timestamps), 0.01 test USDC each, from 0xb24854b51f81649a624e59e17ac2b950e911a5bc (the first three: tx 0x9459d40f…, 0xae8ae5a5…, 0x1e6c13c8…; the rest 17:07–18:23 UTC, all on Base Sepolia). Zone analytics show fourteen matching 200s on /402/pay/base-sepolia from Iraq with the user agent \"node\". Not revenue, not booked; recorded as the second stranger to complete a testnet settlement here",
    "exercised": "SETTLEMENT, end to end on BOTH networks, both client generations against production (2026-08-28). Base Sepolia (test USDC): v2 official @x402/fetch 2.23.0 — tx 0xf35d92c571e4af086b8cf01d87e242e94d6406fff46c5a3c15cbcf787ec31a0c; v1 legacy x402-fetch 1.2.0 via the body and X-PAYMENT — tx 0x0b6b47a003f84096bf59971d665509be2ba54ee467d70dec7c6e5450dffacd62 (both settled by x402.org). Base mainnet (real USDC, a self-test: the payer is project-controlled and the 0.02 USDC moved between our own addresses — booked on /books as working capital, not revenue): v2 tx 0x8a331a0a28a26d290984c34bd12ae03bdc31603856b4e46bace3d2045cddc089; v1 tx 0x629b1a478e88c8be043ee0e8ebac67169a386192fde388b9a616fc850b5010b8 (both settled by xpay). Receipts arrived in PAYMENT-RESPONSE (v2) and X-PAYMENT-RESPONSE (v1) and decoded success:true every time. 2026-10-05: PayAI moved to the front of the mainnet facilitator lists and settled a v2 self-test the same minute — tx 0x9eed7b72bdd445317b1a59e5c7cc12f9a44b857132dcc743121b366261e6ca75 (0.01 USDC between project addresses, booked as a labeled transfer, not revenue). 2026-10-05 16:36:01 UTC: the operator stored the CDP facilitator key, Coinbase's CDP facilitator took the front of the mainnet v2 chain, and settled a v2 self-test — tx 0x30e24c0a8d200180906adf54ba011fd26aa2c4fb070ad78c870debd2d286a748 (block 52214407; 0.01 USDC between project addresses, booked as a labeled transfer, not revenue). 2026-10-09 05:46:01 UTC (block 52367707): a fifth mainnet self-test, the second through CDP — tx 0xba553c25d371527eef124de3151a002b20b276030c1e0368553133098961c6b0 (0.01 USDC between project addresses, booked as a labeled transfer, not revenue) — to keep the CDP Bazaar listing within its 30-day window and to settle a question: the external payment of 2026-10-06 had not moved the listing, and the relayer that broadcast it matches no signer published by PayAI, xpay, Mogami, Heurist or x402.org (CDP publishes none and uses several), so which facilitator settled it is unknown and an external payment cannot be assumed to keep the listing alive. 2026-10-29 21:58:21 UTC (block 53260877): the first paid request to POST /v1/chat/completions, the one resource on this host that sells something real, settled through CDP from the project payer — tx 0xc470ccf5b606317fe64fe5c4db56de92989a2eeed5931ad9da4d2dfdae29857c (0.002 USDC between project addresses, booked as a labeled transfer, not revenue); a first attempt minutes earlier was refused unsettled because the reasoning model returned no text within 120 tokens, as that endpoint promises; a second self-test at 22:22:13 UTC (block 53261593, tx 0xe3f3a1931d28eb4b8bc3024273b8d0a395ce6e5d13c073754e0fc1d1230b8de5, also 0.002 USDC between project addresses, labeled transfer) after the 402 gained its bazaar schema block",
    "catalogues": "Listed in PayAI's public Bazaar (GET https://facilitator.payai.network/discovery/resources?payTo=<receive address>) since 2026-10-05T02:48:53Z, written by that facilitator when it settled the self-test above — its documented and only route in (\"there is no registration form, account, or manual submission\"). Listed in Coinbase's CDP Bazaar since 2026-10-05T16:36Z (GET https://api.cdp.coinbase.com/platform/v2/x402/discovery/merchant?payTo=<receive address>, public, no key), written by that facilitator when it settled the self-test above — the only route in; it stays listed while a settlement through that facilitator happens within its 30-day window — and an external payment through that facilitator counts: on 2026-10-24 and 2026-10-26 the record moved to the second of two external payments (Lumi Trades, Annalist), the first external payments observed to do so (vet402's of 2026-10-06 had not; its facilitator is unknown), and the record's 30-day counters (6 calls, 5 payers on 2026-10-26, against 2 calls, 1 payer after the 2026-10-09 self-test) imply that Lumière PayCheck's and SettledScout's payments went through CDP as well — consistent, not proven — so the window runs from 2026-10-26 and the keep-alive self-test is due only if nothing settles through CDP before it closes. Also listed, by registration, on x402scan, nohumans.directory (paid-verified), x402-list.com and 402index.io. Why it matters: the anonymous buyer of 2026-09-24 paid 92 sellers in two days, 81 of them on x402scan, 66 in the CDP Bazaar, 23 in PayAI's",
    "not_yet_exercised": "a v1 (X-PAYMENT) payment known to be from anyone other than this project; a direct USDC transfer (a donation) rather than an x402 settlement; a payment for any amount other than the default 0.01 (every external settlement so far has been the default); a second purchase by the same observatory (vet402 says it re-buys a listing at most once every 6 days)"
  },
  "for_sale": {
    "url": "https://badhttp.dev/v1/chat/completions",
    "method": "POST",
    "price": "0.002 USDC per request on Base mainnet, flat",
    "what": "an OpenAI-compatible chat completion from Cloudflare Workers AI; the model runs after a facilitator verifies the payment, and the payment settles after the model answers",
    "contract": "https://badhttp.dev/v1",
    "note": "The only paid resource on this host that is not a test fixture. Every /402 route except /402/pay is a paywall that misbehaves on purpose; /402/pay sells nothing but its own receipt."
  },
  "witness": {
    "measured": "2026-10-29T18:52:31.639Z",
    "request_budget": 12,
    "badhttp_version_observed": "0.28.0",
    "worker_version": "2810570b",
    "observations": 180,
    "control_rows": 18,
    "scenarios": 18,
    "data": "https://badhttp.dev/clients.jsonl",
    "data_note": "Every observation is a row of /clients.jsonl with family \"x402\", joined to /corpus.jsonl by corpus_id; /clients indexes them with the class, outcome, description, wire and reference legends and the per-scenario disagreement. The findings below are a reading of those rows, not a second source.",
    "what_this_is": "10 real x402 client libraries and wrappers plus a raw-wire control (curl), one fresh working directory and one fresh client process per cell, each handed the project's throwaway Base Sepolia payer (test USDC, no dollar value) and the library's defaults. Each cell asks the client to GET one /402 URL once; the harness never sends a payment header for a client, so every PAYMENT-SIGNATURE or X-PAYMENT in a row is one the client chose to send, for the amount and on the network it chose. It is a DATED CAPTURE, not a live measurement. Every request the client sent went through a local recording reverse proxy that forwarded it to this service over TLS and returned the response verbatim; the proxy decodes the x402 headers into a summary (never a raw signature), and it cuts a client off after a fixed request budget so a client that signs again forever is bounded by the harness and never by the zone rate limit. The x402 v2 specification says the client reads PAYMENT-REQUIRED, selects a requirement it can satisfy, retries with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and reads PAYMENT-RESPONSE; it says nothing about spending limits, about retrying after a second 402, or about a 500 after a payment. So each row is described against a reference derived from the control's wire exchange: what the offer the server made admits (an offer with nothing a Base Sepolia payer can satisfy admits no payment; /402/pay admits one and delivers a receipt). An outcome describes what the caller received, never a verdict: a client that signs for a very large amount with its defaults and one that stops are both doing something the specification allows, and the finding is the difference. Every figure, list and client name in this block is computed from the rows, never typed, except inside the gated explanations: each of those is written by hand from the client's source as docs/survey-x402-clients-2026-10-29.md read it, and renders only while the computed facts it names still hold.",
    "reading_this": "An outcome is a description of what the caller received (delivered, handed back a status, raised) qualified by whether the client signed; it is never a verdict on the client. The reference is derived from the control's offer, not typed: signing is no-payment-possible, payment-expected or unspecified, and result is stated only for pay.",
    "clients": [
      "Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider 0.10.4 (@x402/fetch 2.29.0) (agent-wrapper)",
      "Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch) 0.22.0 (@faremeter/payment-evm 0.22.0, @faremeter/wallet-evm 0.22.0) (sdk-fetch)",
      "thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment) 5.122.0 (sdk-fetch)",
      "x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1) 1.1.0 (x402 1.2.0, axios 1.21.0, viem 2.57.13) (sdk-http)",
      "@x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment) 2.29.0 (@x402/core 2.29.0, @x402/evm 2.29.0, axios 1.21.0, viem 2.57.13) (sdk-http)",
      "x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) 1.2.0 (x402 1.2.0, viem 2.57.13) (sdk-fetch)",
      "@x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment) 2.29.0 (@x402/core 2.29.0, @x402/evm 2.29.0, viem 2.57.13) (sdk-fetch)",
      "x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment) v0.0.0-20260529172747-45d81d46e5bd (sdk-http)",
      "x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient) 2.26.0 (httpx 0.28.1, eth-account 0.14.0) (sdk-http)",
      "x402 for Python (x402_requests) 2.26.0 (requests 2.34.2, eth-account 0.14.0) (sdk-http)"
    ],
    "control": [
      "curl curl 8.7.1 (x86_64-apple-darwin26.0) libcurl/8.7.1 (SecureTransport) LibreSSL/3.3.6 zlib/1.2.12 nghttp2/1.69.0"
    ],
    "outcome_counts": {
      "delivered/decodable": 9,
      "handed-back/402": 41,
      "raised/after-signing": 14,
      "handed-back/504": 7,
      "handed-back/500": 8,
      "delivered/undecodable": 10,
      "raised/before-signing": 91
    },
    "signed_counts": {
      "signed": 89,
      "not_signed": 91,
      "resigned_at_least_once": 5,
      "receipt_decodable": 9,
      "receipt_undecodable": 10,
      "receipt_absent": 161,
      "resigned_buckets": {
        "0": 84,
        "2-5": 5
      }
    },
    "disagreement_by_scenario": {
      "pay": 2,
      "never": 3,
      "reject": 3,
      "slow": 2,
      "crash": 2,
      "bad-receipt": 1,
      "overpriced": 4,
      "wrong-network": 1,
      "broken/not-base64": 1,
      "broken/not-json": 1,
      "broken/no-accepts": 1,
      "broken/empty-accepts": 1,
      "broken/no-extra": 3,
      "broken/no-resource": 2,
      "broken/version-99": 2,
      "broken/decimal-amount": 1,
      "broken/missing-header": 2,
      "broken/v1-body": 4
    },
    "answers_by_scenario": {
      "pay": [
        {
          "outcome": "delivered/decodable",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/402",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "x402-fetch-v2"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "never": [
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/402",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "2-5",
          "clients": [
            "faremeter-fetch"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "x402-axios-v1"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "reject": [
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/402",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "2-5",
          "clients": [
            "faremeter-fetch"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "x402-axios-v1"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "slow": [
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/504",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-httpx"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "crash": [
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/500",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "bad-receipt": [
        {
          "outcome": "delivered/undecodable",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "overpriced": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "2-5",
          "clients": [
            "faremeter-fetch"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/402",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-go"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "x402-axios-v1"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "wrong-network": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/not-base64": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/not-json": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/no-accepts": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/empty-accepts": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/no-extra": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "2-5",
          "clients": [
            "faremeter-fetch"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/402",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/no-resource": [
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/402",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v1"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/version-99": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/402",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/decimal-amount": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/missing-header": [
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "faremeter-fetch",
            "x402-axios-v1",
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/402",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-go"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "broken/v1-body": [
        {
          "outcome": "handed-back/402",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "agentkit-x402",
            "thirdweb-x402",
            "x402-fetch-v1",
            "x402-httpx",
            "x402-requests"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "2-5",
          "clients": [
            "faremeter-fetch"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/after-signing",
          "signed": true,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "x402-axios-v1"
          ]
        },
        {
          "outcome": "raised/before-signing",
          "signed": false,
          "resigned_bucket": "0",
          "clients": [
            "x402-axios-v2",
            "x402-fetch-v2",
            "x402-go"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    "reference": {
      "pay": {
        "scenario": "pay",
        "signing": "payment-expected",
        "result": "delivered/decodable",
        "note": "the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 1
        }
      },
      "never": {
        "scenario": "never",
        "signing": "payment-expected",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 1
        }
      },
      "reject": {
        "scenario": "reject",
        "signing": "payment-expected",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 1
        }
      },
      "slow": {
        "scenario": "slow",
        "signing": "payment-expected",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 1
        }
      },
      "crash": {
        "scenario": "crash",
        "signing": "payment-expected",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 1
        }
      },
      "bad-receipt": {
        "scenario": "bad-receipt",
        "signing": "payment-expected",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 1
        }
      },
      "overpriced": {
        "scenario": "overpriced",
        "signing": "unspecified",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the requirement asks for 1000000000000 atomic units where the pay control asks for 10000; the specification sets no spending limit",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "1000000000000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 1
        }
      },
      "wrong-network": {
        "scenario": "wrong-network",
        "signing": "no-payment-possible",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "no requirement on eip155:84532 (the offer names eip155:424242)",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:424242"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 2
        }
      },
      "broken/not-base64": {
        "scenario": "broken/not-base64",
        "signing": "no-payment-possible",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the PAYMENT-REQUIRED header does not decode as base64 JSON (not-base64)",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": null,
          "accepts_count": null,
          "networks": [],
          "amount": null,
          "payTo": null,
          "decode_error": "not-base64",
          "body_x402version": null
        }
      },
      "broken/not-json": {
        "scenario": "broken/not-json",
        "signing": "no-payment-possible",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the PAYMENT-REQUIRED header does not decode as base64 JSON (not-json)",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": null,
          "accepts_count": null,
          "networks": [],
          "amount": null,
          "payTo": null,
          "decode_error": "not-json",
          "body_x402version": null
        }
      },
      "broken/no-accepts": {
        "scenario": "broken/no-accepts",
        "signing": "no-payment-possible",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "accepts is absent",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": null,
          "networks": [],
          "amount": null,
          "payTo": null,
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": null
        }
      },
      "broken/empty-accepts": {
        "scenario": "broken/empty-accepts",
        "signing": "no-payment-possible",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "accepts is empty",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 0,
          "networks": [],
          "amount": null,
          "payTo": null,
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": null
        }
      },
      "broken/no-extra": {
        "scenario": "broken/no-extra",
        "signing": "unspecified",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the requirement has no extra, so the EIP-712 domain is missing; nothing forbids a client from guessing one",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": null
        }
      },
      "broken/no-resource": {
        "scenario": "broken/no-resource",
        "signing": "unspecified",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "the payment-required object has no resource, which the signature does not cover",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": null
        }
      },
      "broken/version-99": {
        "scenario": "broken/version-99",
        "signing": "no-payment-possible",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "x402Version is 99, neither 1 nor 2",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 99,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "10000",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": null
        }
      },
      "broken/decimal-amount": {
        "scenario": "broken/decimal-amount",
        "signing": "unspecified",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "amount \"0.01\" is not a string of atomic units, and the specification does not say a client must validate it",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": true,
          "version": 2,
          "accepts_count": 1,
          "networks": [
            "eip155:84532"
          ],
          "amount": "0.01",
          "payTo": "0x2b14ad50d63c7fee5a33847f95153ac37a690170",
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": null
        }
      },
      "broken/missing-header": {
        "scenario": "broken/missing-header",
        "signing": "no-payment-possible",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "there is no PAYMENT-REQUIRED header and the 402 body's x402Version is 2, not 1",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": false,
          "version": null,
          "accepts_count": null,
          "networks": [],
          "amount": null,
          "payTo": null,
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 2
        }
      },
      "broken/v1-body": {
        "scenario": "broken/v1-body",
        "signing": "payment-expected",
        "result": "unspecified",
        "note": "there is no PAYMENT-REQUIRED header and the 402 body is x402Version 1, which carries the same requirement in the v1 form",
        "offer": {
          "header_present": false,
          "version": null,
          "accepts_count": null,
          "networks": [],
          "amount": null,
          "payTo": null,
          "decode_error": null,
          "body_x402version": 1
        }
      }
    },
    "reference_note": "REFERENCE in the /clients x402 family block: per scenario, signing (no-payment-possible | payment-expected | unspecified) and result (delivered/decodable for pay only), derived from the control's offer, with a note naming the clause that produced it",
    "findings": [
      "10 x402 client libraries or wrappers (Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests)) were each handed one throwaway Base Sepolia payer and asked to GET each of 18 /402 URLs once, with the library's defaults and no payment header sent by the harness — 180 rows in all. Every payment header below is one the client chose to send. By what the caller received: 91 raised/before-signing, 41 handed-back/402, 14 raised/after-signing, 10 delivered/undecodable, 9 delivered/decodable, 8 handed-back/500, 7 handed-back/504. 89 of 180 rows signed at least one authorization.",
      "On pay, the one paywall that settles (0.01 test USDC): 8 clients (@x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests)) paid with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE; 2 clients (x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1)) paid with X-PAYMENT. The server reads PAYMENT-SIGNATURE (x402 v2) and X-PAYMENT (x402 v1) alike and answers each in its own generation's receipt header.",
      "On pay, 9 of 10 clients delivered the body with a decodable receipt (@x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests), x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1)); the rest: all 1 clients signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and handed back a 402.",
      "On pay, the paid request of 1 client (@x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment)) was answered 402 by this server with the facilitator's verify verdict as the error (\"invalid_exact_evm_transaction_failed\"); each had signed the offered amount to the offered address, so that is a statement about the Base Sepolia facilitator chain at that minute, not about the client.",
      "On overpriced, where the offer asks for 1,000,000 USDC, 4 of 10 clients signed an authorization with their defaults (1,000,000 USDC: Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1)); 6 did not sign (all 6 clients raised before signing anything). The x402 specification has no spending limit, so a client that signs and one that stops are both inside it; the authorization expires after 300 seconds and this server discards it.",
      "On never, a paywall that answers 402 to every payment, 10 of 10 clients signed; signing again after the second 402: @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests), x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) 0 times; Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch) 2 times. Outcomes: @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) handed back a 402; Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1) raised after signing.",
      "On reject, a paywall that rejects every payment with a reason (reference: payment-expected, since the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's): @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and handed back a 402; Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE, then signed again 2 times and raised after signing; x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT and handed back a 402; x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT and raised after signing.",
      "On slow, a paywall that sits on a paid request and answers 504 (reference: payment-expected, since the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's): @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402_requests) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and handed back a 504; @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and raised after signing; x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT and handed back a 504; x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT and raised after signing.",
      "On crash, a paywall that answers 500 after the payment (reference: payment-expected, since the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's): @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and handed back a 500; @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and raised after signing; x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT and handed back a 500; x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT and raised after signing.",
      "On bad-receipt, a paywall whose receipt header is not decodable (reference: payment-expected, since the offer carries a requirement on eip155:84532 equal to the pay control's): @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and delivered the body with a receipt that did not decode; x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT and delivered the body with a receipt that did not decode.",
      "On wrong-network, whose only option is on a network that does not exist (reference: no-payment-possible, since no requirement on eip155:84532 (the offer names eip155:424242)): all 10 clients signed nothing and raised before signing anything.",
      "On empty-accepts, an offer whose accepts list is empty (reference: no-payment-possible, since accepts is empty): all 10 clients signed nothing and raised before signing anything.",
      "On decimal-amount, an offer whose amount is a decimal string (reference: unspecified, since amount \"0.01\" is not a string of atomic units, and the specification does not say a client must validate it): all 10 clients signed nothing and raised before signing anything.",
      "On v1-body, a spec-valid x402 v1 offer in the body and no PAYMENT-REQUIRED header (reference: payment-expected, since there is no PAYMENT-REQUIRED header and the 402 body is x402Version 1, which carries the same requirement in the v1 form): Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT and handed back a 402; @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment) signed nothing and raised before signing anything; x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT and raised after signing; Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch) signed 0.01 USDC with X-PAYMENT, then signed again 2 times and raised after signing.",
      "On missing-header, a 402 with no PAYMENT-REQUIRED header (reference: no-payment-possible, since there is no PAYMENT-REQUIRED header and the 402 body's x402Version is 2, not 1): @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests), x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) signed nothing and raised before signing anything; thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and handed back a 402.",
      "On not-base64 (reference: no-payment-possible, since the PAYMENT-REQUIRED header does not decode as base64 JSON (not-base64)): all 10 clients signed nothing and raised before signing anything.",
      "On not-json (reference: no-payment-possible, since the PAYMENT-REQUIRED header does not decode as base64 JSON (not-json)): all 10 clients signed nothing and raised before signing anything.",
      "On no-accepts (reference: no-payment-possible, since accepts is absent): all 10 clients signed nothing and raised before signing anything.",
      "On no-extra (reference: unspecified, since the requirement has no extra, so the EIP-712 domain is missing; nothing forbids a client from guessing one): @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) signed nothing and raised before signing anything; thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and handed back a 402; Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE, then signed again 2 times and raised after signing.",
      "On no-resource (reference: unspecified, since the payment-required object has no resource, which the signature does not cover): @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and handed back a 402; Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) signed nothing and raised before signing anything.",
      "On version-99 (reference: no-payment-possible, since x402Version is 99, neither 1 nor 2): @x402/axios (wrapAxiosWithPayment), @x402/fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment), Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) signed nothing and raised before signing anything; thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests) signed 0.01 USDC with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE and handed back a 402.",
      "On v1-body, where the offer carries no PAYMENT-REQUIRED header, 7 of 10 clients signed (Coinbase AgentKit x402 action provider, Faremeter (@faremeter/fetch), thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient), x402 for Python (x402_requests), x402-axios (withPaymentInterceptor, v1), x402-fetch (wrapFetchWithPayment, v1) with X-PAYMENT); the others signed nothing.",
      "On missing-header, where the offer carries no PAYMENT-REQUIRED header, 2 of 10 clients signed (thirdweb x402 (wrapFetchWithPayment), x402 for Go (WrapHTTPClientWithPayment) with PAYMENT-SIGNATURE); the others signed nothing.",
      "Why those four signed on overpriced, as their sources read (docs/survey-x402-clients-2026-10-29.md, section 1 \"Default spending limits\" and sections 2.4-2.9): none of them has a spending limit unless the caller sets one. thirdweb's fetchWithPayment tests options.maxValue only when it is given (fetchWithPayment.js:85-88), Faremeter's exact EVM handler signs requirements.amount as offered (payment-evm exact/client.js:39-45), the Go client's selector has no amount check (client.go:228-262), and x402-axios 1.1.0's interceptor has none (index.mjs:15-49).",
      "Why the other six refused before signing (docs/survey-x402-clients-2026-10-29.md, section 1): @x402/core's default spend control is $1 per payment on its default assets (client/index.mjs:21, DEFAULT_MAX_AMOUNT_PER_PAYMENT), shared by @x402/fetch, @x402/axios and AgentKit, which wraps @x402/fetch; the Python client has the same $1 default (client_base.py:185); x402-fetch 1.2.0 caps at 0.1 USDC (index.mjs:15) and throws \"Payment amount exceeds maximum allowed\".",
      "Why Faremeter alone signed again on never (docs/survey-x402-clients-2026-10-29.md, sections 2.2-2.9): @faremeter/fetch repeats the whole sequence (unpaid request, sign, paid request) up to retryCount + 1 = 3 times with a doubling 100 ms delay whenever the paid request is answered 402 (fetch.js:72-82), then throws WrappedFetchError carrying the last 402 (fetch.js:83-86). Every other roster client makes exactly one paid retry and hands the second 402 back or raises it (@x402/fetch index.mjs:75; @x402/axios index.mjs:59-71; AgentKit through @x402/fetch, section 2.7; thirdweb fetchWithPayment.js:123; x402-fetch index.mjs:39-41; x402-axios index.mjs:28-30; Python httpx.py:102 and requests.py:110; Go http/client.go:168).",
      "Why @x402/fetch, @x402/axios and the Go client signed nothing on v1-body (docs/survey-x402-clients-2026-10-29.md, sections 2.2 and 2.9): all three read a v1 body (@x402/core chunk-4NCAR6KR.mjs:2257-2266; Go http/client.go:436-466) but each pays it only with a v1 scheme registered, and the harness registered the exact EVM scheme for eip155:84532 in the quick-start form (x402Client.fromConfig with an ExactEvmScheme; Register(network, ...) in Go), which registers x402 v2 only; @x402/core then throws \"No client registered for x402 version: 1\" (client/index.mjs:253-257) and Go returns unsupported_scheme. @x402/evm's registerExactEvmScheme helper also registers the v1 scheme for the matching plain network names (chunk-GNHGHC3E.mjs:152-160), as the Python register_exact_evm_client helper does (register.py:27-76), , which is why both Python clients signed the v1 body with X-PAYMENT.",
      "Why thirdweb and the Go client signed on missing-header (docs/survey-x402-clients-2026-10-29.md, sections 2.4 and 2.9): both read the 402 body when the PAYMENT-REQUIRED header is absent and take the version from the body (thirdweb's parsePaymentRequired, x402/schemas.js:97-106 and fetchWithPayment.js:59-65; the Go RoundTripper, http/client.go:436-466), where @x402/core, the Python client and Faremeter accept a body only when it says x402Version 1 (chunk-4NCAR6KR.mjs:2257-2266; x402_http_client_base.py:121-150; @faremeter/fetch internal.js:36-66).",
      "Why @x402/fetch, @x402/axios and AgentKit raised before signing on no-extra (docs/survey-x402-clients-2026-10-29.md, section 2.2): @x402/evm's scheme requires extra.name and extra.version before it signs (chunk-KWP3UD2B.mjs:71); the two v1 libraries read only the body, which carries no accepts on this flavor (section 2.5). Faremeter signed because its handler falls back to the asset's default EIP-712 name and version when extra is absent (payment-evm exact/client.js:47-63, section 2.6); where thirdweb, the Go client and the Python client took their domain values from is not traced in the survey.",
      "Why six clients refused the x402Version 99 offer (docs/survey-x402-clients-2026-10-29.md, sections 2.2, 2.5 and 2.6): @x402/core throws \"No client registered for x402 version: 99\" (client/index.mjs:253-257), Faremeter's schema requires version 2 (internal.js:36-66), and the two v1 libraries read only the body, which carries no accepts on this flavor. thirdweb signed because it takes the version from the payload when it is a number and names the payment header after it (x402/schemas.js:106, x402/headers.js:9-12, section 2.4); why the Go and Python clients signed is not traced in the survey.",
      "0 of 180 rows hit the harness's cap, 0 were cut off by the request budget and 0 failed to land. Every other row is a response this server sent, read back from the wire with its x-badhttp-version on every exchange it answered — except 1 exchange where the client hung up before any response byte arrived, with no x-badhttp-version to read (x402 for Python (x402HttpxClient) on slow)."
    ],
    "what_this_cannot_say": "Anything over HTTPS or HTTP/2 (every client spoke HTTP/1.1 to a loopback recorder); what a client does with mainnet funds (the payer holds test USDC on Base Sepolia only, and no cell offers eip155:8453); whether a client that signed for 1,000,000 USDC would have been charged by a server that kept the authorization (this one discards it, and the expiry is 300 seconds); a hosted-wallet or smart-wallet signer (every roster client signs with a local key); a client configured with a spending limit it does not set by default (the configuration is the library's defaults); anything after the harness caps or the request budget.",
    "not_in_roster": [
      {
        "client": "@x402/mcp 2.29.0 (about 10,600 downloads a week)",
        "reason": "pays tool calls made through an MCP client and server, so it cannot be pointed at an HTTP GET of one URL"
      },
      {
        "client": "mcpay 0.1.17 (about 240)",
        "reason": "an SDK and command-line proxy for MCP servers with payments; it depends on x402-fetch and takes an MCP server, not a URL"
      },
      {
        "client": "agentcash 0.17.1 command-line client (about 1,200)",
        "reason": "its networks are base, solana and tempo (the only EVM chain id in its source is eip155:8453), it keeps its wallet in a file under the user's home directory and defaults to a USD 5 limit; it has no Base Sepolia network, so it cannot sign any cell of the grid"
      },
      {
        "client": "@circle-fin/x402-batching 4.0.0 (about 23,000)",
        "reason": "its GatewayClient.pay() signs only an offer that advertises Circle Gateway batching; against /402/pay it raised No Gateway batching option available for network eip155:84532 after one unpaid request and signed nothing, and no cell advertises that option"
      },
      {
        "client": "x402-safe-fetch 0.9.0 (about 980)",
        "reason": "pays a USD 0.001 pre-flight check to a third-party service before it pays any endpoint, so it sends the target URL to that service"
      },
      {
        "client": "@alchemy/x402 0.6.6 (about 660)",
        "reason": "built for the Alchemy gateway; its pay command takes a PAYMENT-REQUIRED header as an argument rather than fetching a URL"
      },
      {
        "client": "@acedatacloud/x402-client (about 320)",
        "reason": "supplies signatures to one vendor's SDK and is not a client of its own"
      },
      {
        "client": "@atxp/x402, @b3dotfun/anyspend-x402-fetch, @fastxyz/x402-client, @payai/x402-fetch, @mingderwang/x402, @obul.ai/obulx, @bankofai/x402-cli (each under 130 downloads a week)",
        "reason": "too few downloads to represent what developers use; not surveyed beyond their descriptions"
      },
      {
        "client": "@coinbase/x402 2.1.0 (about 98,000)",
        "reason": "the package's own description calls it the Coinbase facilitator package; it configures a facilitator and is not a client"
      },
      {
        "client": "x402-reqwest 2.0.2 and x402-rs (Rust; about 2,500 and 760 downloads over 90 days)",
        "reason": "needs a Rust toolchain this machine lacks"
      },
      {
        "client": "purl (Rust command-line client, a few dozen release downloads)",
        "reason": "ships only as a Rust program; this survey did not build or run it"
      },
      {
        "client": "x402-axios 1.2.1 (npm latest)",
        "reason": "cannot be installed: its dependency x402@^1.2.1 is not on npm (the roster uses 1.1.0)"
      }
    ],
    "reproduce": "Run scripts/x402-witness/all.sh in the source (it needs X402_WITNESS_PAYER_KEY, a throwaway Base Sepolia key holding test USDC only, and refuses to run with TLS verification off or while the smoke suite runs), then node scripts/witness-parse-x402.mjs on the capture it writes to regenerate src/witness-x402-data.js. By hand: point the row's client at the row's url with the payer registered for eip155:84532 and nothing else changed, and compare the requests it sent and what the caller received with the row; for the reference, fetch the same url with curl -sS --http1.1 and read the offer. Pace the calls against the zone limit of 100 per 10 s, and treat a response without x-badhttp-version as no observation.",
    "capture": "docs/probe-x402-clients-2026-10-29.jsonl",
    "run_log": "docs/probe-x402-clients-2026-10-29.log"
  }
}
